It’s one thing to go on “Saturday Night Live” and deliver a sexist rant. It’s another to climb online and defend it – and abandon your fellow women in the process.
To be clear, both are bad.
This past weekend, comedian Shane Gillis hosted the long-running sketch comedy show. A show he was fired from, it merits mentioning, due to racist “jokes” of his that resurfaced not long after he was hired.
Gillis – who hosts the extremely popular “Matt and Shane’s Secret Podcast” alongside fellow stand-up comedian Matt McCusker, and who pals around with the likes of controversial commentator Joe Rogan – used his opening monologue to remind us of his character. “I haven’t been to the gym in so long. I didn’t know women just dress like whores now?” he quipped. “The shorts. Have you seen the shorts?”
For one thing, it’s not funny. Not just because it’s offensive, but because it’s lazy humor that punches down in pursuit of landing its observational blow – this time, on women. Not that the comedy world has ever been great to women. It’s a space where women are chronically under-hired and underpaid, not to mention routinely harassed, onstage and behind the scenes.
But this is also an especially ill-timed joke to make, as we continue to discuss sexual assault on college campuses (and beyond) – and the ways in which men’s permissiveness of other men’s bad behavior makes matters tangibly worse.
Try telling that to Gillis’ defenders, though – which somehow includes women.
The Women Who Coddle Ne’er-Do-Well Men
Gillis’ monologue was defended by the usual crowd of anonymous internet bros who were likely thrilled by one of their own getting to call women “whores” on national television without recourse.
But joining them in the online fray were women who crowed about the hypersensitivity of other women, and the ways in which we invite our own harm by wearing shorts and tank tops to the gym – insinuating that we are “asking for it.”
I’m not putting words in people’s mouths. Writer Lisa Britton posted on X to her roughly 75,000 followers that “It’s the ‘Look at me! But don’t you dare look at me’ ways of many women today. I think the ‘conversation’ that needs to be had is women, in many ways, embracing accountability for their choices.”
Allie Voss, a communications director working in the energy sector who bills herself as “Oppenheimer Barbie” to her 36,000-strong following, joined in by sharing several women’s gym selfies with the caption: “Guys, please wear clothes to the gym; it’s not that hard.”
Others, meanwhile, took the opportunity to further their own causes. “Spare me the white knighting for women if you’ve been silent on the ACTUAL misogynistic attack on women’s sports [in] our locker rooms, our bathrooms and other spaces,” conservative radio host and former NRA spokesperson Dana Loesch posted on X, where over 1.3 million people follow her. Loesch, who has a history of transphobic statements, was referring to the ongoing debate around trans women’s participation in sports.
It’d be easy to dismiss what they’re saying as reactive online chatter – except, each of them is reaching thousands, if not millions of people when they publish something. And, each of their X posts are full of replies from women joining in the dogpile – as well as men patting them all on the head for being a voice of reason.
So Why Do It?
By green-lighting Gillis’ behavior, these women are directly contributing to a world that’s tougher and more perilous for their fellow women.
Research backs this assertion. One study from the University of Surrey found that women’s objectification in mainstream media fosters sexist beliefs in young men. Such humor also has detrimental effects on women’s well-being, another study revealed. And yes, such humor heightens men’s tendencies to assault.
“Humor helps to create the culture that we all live in, including the social rules about what is and isn’t acceptable within that culture,” psychologist Gill Harrop wrote for Psychology Today. “That may seem harmless to those making the jokes, but for those who find themselves repeatedly cast as the punchline, the cumulative effect can be exhausting,”
Why would someone willingly participate in fostering such a culture – to their own detriment?
To understand why, look no farther than the women who once worked for and defended President Donald Trump, a man who is study-proven to have worsened sexism in the U.S. through rhetoric and policy. Or the women who publicly agreed that the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy proves that we should revisit women’s right to vote.
These women are trying to protect their status by ingratiating themselves with oppressors. But it’s a tactic that never works. Most of those female Trump staffers have lost their jobs, often in public and humiliating ways. The women calling for a repeal of the 19th Amendment wouldn’t miraculously preserve their own rights while we lose out – they’d be rendered voiceless, too.
The women defending Gillis need to wake up and understand that their liberation cannot be won by caging other women, that their ascent cannot happen by stepping upon other women’s backs.
And men need to start speaking up. Actor Dan Levy led that charge by publicly decrying the monologue. “Women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores – it makes the men calling them ‘whores’ misogynists,” he said. Complacency from men “has created the environment in which women are sexually assaulted and it’s a ‘conversation’ as opposed to a ‘crime.’”
Women, meanwhile, can always opt to take our cues from the likes of “Saturday Night Live” alumna Ego Nwodim, who posted a gym selfie to her Instagram Stories with the simple caption: “Whore reporting for duty.”
Now that’s funny. ◼️