Turning Point USA host an annual Young Women's Leadership Summit, such as this one in 2022 in Grapevine, Texas. (Credit: Gage Skidmore, Flickr)
Turning Point USA host an annual Young Women’s Leadership Summit, such as this one in 2022 in Grapevine, Texas. (Credit: Gage Skidmore, Flickr)

In the conclusion of our “Invented” podcast series (listen to Episodes 1 and 2), we take a look at the far-right forces driving much of the renewed interest in housewives and traditional gender roles. Just like in the 1950s, the mentality of “a women’s place is in the home” has seeped back into American culture. For example, we look at how football player Harrison Butker’s controversial commencement address at Benedictine College in 2024 eerily mirrors presidential nominee Adlai Stevenson’s address to Smith College in 1955. 

“They are really selling this dream, exactly like they did before,” says Kristen Thompson, who researched 1950s housewives for her master’s thesis at University of Massachusetts. “It’s almost word-for-word exact, talking to these college educated women at the peak of their academic careers, [saying] that the best thing you’ll ever be is a wife and a mother, which is insulting at best and just horrifying at worst.”

Also in this episode, we talk to Madeline Peltz, author of “Good Girls and Alpha Males: How The Conservative Media Is Targeting Gen Z,” and Catherine Rottenberg, a professor at Goldsmiths, University of London. 

Peltz thinks we may soon be seeing less of the tradwife. She points to the buzzy publication of “Yesteryear,” the novel by Caro Claire Burke. “I personally think that ‘Yesteryear’ is the high watermark for the tradwife thing,” she says. “The cultural fascination with tradwives is on the way out.”

Could massive transformation be on the way in? Join us for the final installment of our 3-part podcast series, Invented: The Myth of the American Housewife.

More In This Series 

Episode 1
Meet the Cold War-Era Housewife, Complete with Pearls and Aprons
With men back from World War II, working women are thrust back into the home – and become a potent new symbol of the American way of life. 

Episode 2
When Never-Ending Domesticity Isn’t As Blissful As It Seems
In the 1950s and 60s, women relegated to the home turn to martinis and “mother’s little helper.” Behind the glossy sheen of social media, today’s tradwives face similar struggles. 

Read Full Transcript

COLLEEN: Hi, I’m Colleen DeBaise.

VICTORIA: And I’m Victoria Flexner.

COLLEEN: This is Part 3 of “Invented.” We’re continuing our conversation about 1950s housewives

VICTORIA: and their modern-day equivalent, the tradwives, which we’re exploring in this episode.

COLLEEN: So picture this: you’re a woman who has spent the past four years getting your diploma, and your commencement speaker, a popular guy, is on stage.

COLLEEN: He takes a moment to speak to the women in the audience.

HARRISON BUTKER: I can tell you that my beautiful wife Isabelle would be the first to say that her life truly started when she began living her vocation as a wife.

VICTORIA: That is Harrison Butker, a player with the Kansas City Chiefs, giving the address at Benedictine College in 2024. He had a message for the men, too.

HARRISON BUTKER: Be unapologetic in your masculinity, fighting against the cultural emasculation of men.

COLLEEN: But let’s get back to his advice for women.

HARRISON BUTKER: I think it is you, the women, who have had the most diabolical lies told to you. Some of you may go on to lead successful careers in the world, but I would venture to guess that the majority of you are most excited about your marriage and the children you will bring into this world.

KRISTEN THOMPSON: They are really selling this dream, exactly like they did before.

COLLEEN: That’s Kristen Thompson, who we’ve been speaking to for this series. She researched 1950s housewives for her master’s thesis, and she’s seeing a lot of history repeating itself with today’s tradwives.

KRISTEN THOMPSON: I don’t think the patterns themselves are as surprising. I think the blatancy with which it is so almost verbatim repeating itself is the shock.

VICTORIA: As we talked about in our first episode (give it a listen), over 70 years ago, two-time presidential nominee Adlai Stevenson gave a controversial speech at Smith College, encouraging female graduates to embrace their roles as wives and mothers.

KRISTEN THOMPSON: The commencement speech given just a few years ago by Harrison Butker eerily, eerily mirrors one that was given decades prior. And it’s almost word for word exact, talking to these college-educated women at the peak of their academic careers, ready to go off into life. And they just say over and over, both times and over and over again, that the best thing you’ll ever be is a wife and a mother, which is insulting at best and just horrifying at worst. But I think the shocking thing is just how exact the copies are.

COLLEEN: I want to pick up on a word Kristen just used: “blatancy.” It’s a good way to describe how openly some hyper-traditional concepts are being spoken about in conservative circles.

VICTORIA: Yes. It’s worth noting that neither you nor I belong to these circles, so we don’t see it, at least not every day. But that’s why I called up Madeline Peltz.

MADELINE PELTZ: I’m a writer and a journalist.

VICTORIA: She spent many years at Media Matters for America, the progressive media watchdog group

MADELINE PELTZ: before I left to write my book Good Girls and Alpha Males: How the Conservative Media Is Targeting Gen Z.

VICTORIA: And most importantly, for the purposes of this podcast

MADELINE PELTZ: I’ve spent the last several years on the ground in the conservative youth movement.

VICTORIA: Turning Point USA is a huge part of this movement.

MADELINE PELTZ: For anyone who doesn’t know, Turning Point is the largest conservative youth organization in the country. It was founded by Charlie Kirk in 2012 and has since grown into an absolute digital media juggernaut.

VICTORIA: Madeline has attended its annual conferences.

MADELINE PELTZ: Turning Point events are like full-fledged productions. I think a lot of the world was shocked at Charlie Kirk’s memorial when Erika Kirk walked out to these sparklers. It seemed very inappropriate, and WWE, and it was, but that’s also the Turning Point way. They do those sparklers for every speaker.

VICTORIA: Turning Point also hosts an annual Women’s Conference.

MADELINE PELTZ: Which happens every summer, that I’ve been to twice, it is a Instagrammable paradise of photo-ready moments and your favorite female podcasters. This year, they had a Pilates class where all the girls went and took Pilates. The last year I was there, which was 2025, they did line dancing and custom trucker hat-making, where they put appliqués on trucker hats.

VICTORIA: Yes. It sounds almost like a festival, like there’s going to be a flower wall and matcha as well or something, you know what I mean? [laughs]

MADELINE PELTZ: There’s definitely a flower wall. [laughs]

MADELINE PELTZ: This year at the Women’s Leadership Summit, you have multiple speakers on the stage, Savannah Faith Stone, Alex Clark, who’s the face of Turning Point’s outreach to young women, have both said that women should defer their vote to their husband through a system they call household voting.

COLLEEN: Savannah Stone, for those unaware, is a 21-year-old tradwife. If you look at her Instagram, she’s a striking brunette with long flowing hair, and sometimes she’s applying makeup as she talks.

SAVANNAH STONE: You can’t just want a husband, you have to also want to be a wife.

MADELINE PELTZ: She’s had an explosive rise just in the last couple of months.

COLLEEN: Here’s an interview she did earlier this year on the podcast “Next Generation,” which went viral.

MALE HOST: Why shouldn’t women vote?

SAVANNAH STONE: So I believe in a one-family voting system. I think it would bring back the nuclear family. I believe that the husband and wife are one flesh and therefore should make that political decision together. And I don’t want these radical feminists to vote, quite frankly. Like, that’s my logic behind it. Since the 19th Amendment, society has decayed because women’s interests have become the focal point of politics.

MADELINE PELTZ: We’re talking, like, in the last couple of months, in terms of her popularity, there’s a whole other universe of a strain of Christianity that is well connected in the Trump administration that is very much against the 19th Amendment.

DALE PARTRIDGE: Is it good that women can vote in America? I don’t think so.

VICTORIA: That’s Dale Partridge, pastor of the King’s Way Reformed Church in Arizona.

DALE PARTRIDGE: Nearly every legalized atrocity of the last 100 years was made possible by the female vote.

COLLEEN: There’s also Doug Wilson, an even more prominent pastor from Christ Church in Idaho, who advocates for individual voting to be replaced by household voting. Here he is, explaining things to NPR’s Leila Fadel.

DOUG WILSON: The vote would be cast by the head of the household.

LEILA FADEL: Which would typically be

DOUG WILSON: The man.

LEILA FADEL: The man.

COLLEEN: He also believes women shouldn’t hold office, and in case there is any confusion

LEILA FADEL: You’ve called for repealing women’s right to vote, which is protected by the 19th Amendment.

DOUG WILSON: Right.

LEILA FADEL: Why?

DOUG WILSON: Because it’s a good idea. [chuckles]

MADELINE PELTZ: They have extremely regressive views on family formation and gender. Their stated explicit goal is to take over government and remake it in the image of Christian nationalism. These people are dead serious. They are really serious.

VICTORIA: Madeline attended a Christ Church service earlier this year.

MADELINE PELTZ: This church set up an outpost in DC just a couple steps away from the Capitol. I saw Heritage Foundation staffers there. It was a lot of young families with young children. I turned around and there was Pete Hegseth, which was really surreal and shocking.

VICTORIA: Hegseth, the secretary of defense, also invited Wilson to give a sermon at the Pentagon.

COLLEEN: We should point out that Wilson and other Christian nationalists also believe homosexuality is a sin, and they’ve downplayed how bad slavery was.

MADELINE PELTZ: Now we’re in the middle of this big mainstream conversation about whether women want the right to vote or not. I think one thing that came out of the Turning Point conference this summer was this video of young women saying they would give up their right to vote if it got rid of things like abortion.

COLLEEN: Here’s a clip of that, from media group NowThis Impact.

YOUNG WOMAN: As a Christian woman, honestly, I would be OK with giving up my right to vote.

WOMAN INTERVIEWER: Do you think your daughter should have the right to vote?

MOM: I’d be OK if she didn’t, because I also know she’s going to marry a biblical man.

ANOTHER YOUNG WOMAN: I would as well give up my vote if it got rid of things like abortion.

VICTORIA: I mean, all of this is really disturbing, and shows how suggestible this audience is.

MADELINE PELTZ: I think it comes from being raised in really patriarchal churches, where you are conditioned to sit and listen and take seriously anything that is put in front of you. I think that when you have someone on stage suggesting that maybe women shouldn’t have the right to vote, that catches on quite quickly with this crowd in particular.

VICTORIA: You know something I’ve been wondering while we’ve been working on this series? Is the tradwife having a moment in the zeitgeist right now for a multitude of reasons

COLLEEN: Right

VICTORIA: Is this just partly a natural reaction to “girlboss culture”

COLLEEN: which was pushed so much in the 2010s by Sophia Amoruso, Sheryl Sandberg?

SHERYL SANDBERG: Do not lean back. Lean in!

VICTORIA: Or is it an image, an ideal, that is being specifically promoted by special interest groups? I asked Madeline.

MADELINE PELTZ: I think it’s hard to say. When it comes to Turning Point, which is what I’ve looked at the most closely, certainly there is a well-moneyed campaign to push this type of message. You’re talking about millions of dollars and a message about gender roles that really became the center of the Turning Point message.

VICTORIA: In March of this year, Madeline made a short documentary about tradwives, looking at how right-wing activists and investors are behind a women’s magazine called Evie, dubbed the conservative Cosmo, and a period-tracking app, 28Wellness, which discourages the use of birth control.

COLLEEN: The 28 app raised $3.2 million in seed funding from Peter Thiel, the prominent conservative investor.

VICTORIA: Here’s a clip from Madeline’s documentary, which was made for “More Perfect Union,” a progressive media nonprofit.

MADELINE PELTZ (FROM DOCUMENTARY): This fits right into the larger reactionary right-wing movement led by groups like the Heritage Foundation and the Federalist Society. They’ve spent decades dismantling the social safety net established in the New Deal and chipping away at reproductive rights. And their scheming paid off big in 2022 when they overturned Roe v. Wade. Even trad wife influencers who aren’t overtly political, their lives track well onto the 1950s-inspired conservative vision of America: a Christian family with a man at the head and a subservient wife. He goes out to work, she joyfully keeps the home and minds the children.

VICTORIA: And as Madeline points out, the efforts seem to be working.

MADELINE PELTZ: In 2024, the youth vote had its largest swing towards Republicans in 20 years, especially with young white women. Democrats were stuck in outdated girlboss messaging.

VICTORIA: But while conservative forces are making big gains on a federal level, does that directly correlate to the popularity of tradwives?

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: Listen, I think we have to be very careful about giving it too much attention, because it’s really a marginal phenomenon.

VICTORIA: That’s Catherine Rottenberg.

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: I’m a professor of Media, Communications and Cultural Studies at Goldsmiths. My previous research that is particularly related to this is around what I call the rise of neoliberal feminism.

VICTORIA: Catherine pointed out that perhaps this entire tradwife movement is not as huge as it may appear on TikTok.

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: Again, how big is the phenomenon? I’m not sure that it’s so big.

VICTORIA: Because, as she points out

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: How many of us could actually monetize it in a way that would allow us to continue that lifestyle? It is also thinking through the political economy of this. There may be larger forces, but these women are both reflecting and creating this larger cultural shift. We have to also be wary of not overstating how popular it is. It’s fascinating. We’re preoccupied with it. That also tells us, why are we preoccupied?

VICTORIA: Madeline, for her part, thinks we may soon be seeing less of the tradwife, at least on social media. She points to the buzzy publication of Yesteryear, the novel by Caro Claire Burke.

MADELINE PELTZ: I personally think that Yesteryear is the high watermark for the tradwife thing. I think that the cultural fascination with tradwives is on its way out. Women who voted for Trump, especially on their attraction or association with the Make America Healthy Again movement, women are increasingly at odds with the administration and disaffected.

COLLEEN: Vic, you and I have talked about how super-liberal feminists (like ourselves) and super-conservative tradwives both feel a lot of dissatisfaction with the state of women in the world.

VICTORIA: Right, but where we differ is what we see as solutions to this problem. I asked Madeline about that.

VICTORIA: What is the tradwife movement rejecting? Is it just a rejection of girlboss culture? Is it also just a way to put your head down and not get too lost in the enormity of the world’s problems at this point in time?

MADELINE PELTZ: I think it could be all of those things. It’s worthwhile to drill down on what that means.

VICTORIA: Gen Z women today were growing up in the mid-2010s, which was peak girlboss.

MADELINE PELTZ: That was the era that they breathed as they were being taught about what they would grow up and inherit as a woman in the world. I think you get into the workforce, and you find a very different reality. It’s just highly improbable, this argument that Sheryl Sandberg was making and Sophia Amoruso, who invented the girlboss

VICTORIA: Oh, yes.

MADELINE PELTZ: They were saying that work was the path to liberation. That’s just extremely improbable for most women. You don’t go to work to find freedom. Work is necessary to have what tiny modicum of freedom and control over your own life that you are seeking to exercise. Most of the working class and the majority of the working poor are women. The majority of people who are working minimum wage jobs are women. Those aren’t women who are going to find an upward ladder through work.

COLLEEN: Not to mention, there continues to be very limited resources or support for women who are raising kids or taking care of elderly parents.

VICTORIA: Madeline had this to say about some of the conservative young women she’s seen attending Turning Point conferences.

MADELINE PELTZ: There is a tremendous disconnect between what figures like Charlie Kirk were saying, and now his successors are saying, about the role of women in society, and what these young women who are in the audience are thinking about their own lives. If you speak to these conservative young women, they’ll tell you they aspire to marriage for sure, they want kids, that’s not that radical of an idea, and they also want a life outside of that. They will pretty closely describe a work-life balance that you might hear from a young liberal woman. I think that it’s important to distinguish between what these right-wing media figures are saying and how young women are receiving it.

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: A lot of their complaints are very similar to feminist concerns.

VICTORIA: That’s Catherine Rottenberg again.

CATHERINE ROTTENBERG: It’s, again, thinking through some of this girlboss. The girlboss is a displacement, I think, for, again, a certain kind of toxic workplace, always on, which many of us will be very familiar with. I think in many ways, the girlboss, like feminism, becomes a target. It’s a displacement of rage and anger that these women have, and of many of us. It’s just the direction in which they push their anger is split.

COLLEEN: It’s interesting to consider that, when you strip away the ridiculousness and the over-the-top messaging of tradwives on social media, there’s actually some common ground with progressive feminists.

VICTORIA: Yeah. I think it’s important to distinguish between tradwives and tradwife influencers. For a lot of conservative women, similar to their liberal counterparts, they take issue with the current position of women in society.

VICTORIA: I think most Americans on either side are fed up, and things aren’t necessarily working out for the average person.

MADELINE PELTZ: The Big Beautiful Bill is the largest clawback of social safety net programs since these programs were implemented.

DONALD TRUMP: Thank you all for being here to support the most important pieces of legislation in the history of our country.

MADELINE PELTZ: Some of the work requirements for SNAP benefits are going into effect now. Medicaid pays for 40% of all births in this country, 50% in rural areas. People who are family-values oriented are going to increasingly find how difficult it is to support your family, already, not to mention in the future as these cuts are implemented. I think that is going to continue to push people away from Trumpism, as the hollowness of these promises comes increasingly more evident.

VICTORIA: We’ll be right back.

The Story Exchange is a nonprofit media platform dedicated to elevating women’s work, including that of trailblazing women scientists working to find innovative, science-based solutions to climate change. Check out our annual list of Women to Watch in Science at TheStoryExchange.org.

1950s PSA, MALE VOICE: The women of this family seem to feel like they owe it to the man of the family to look relaxed, rested and attractive at dinnertime.

1950s PSA: Mother, too, keeps a good appearance, even around the house, for that keeps up her spirits.

ANYA: Look, being a tradwife, it’s not just about wearing sundresses and making sourdough all day.

JANEA: I give him a warm meal when he comes home, the house is clean, his laundry is done.

COLLEEN: When we set out to do this series, we saw similarities between 1950s housewives, people like my mom and your grandmother

VICTORIA: and the women, online and offline, who identify as traditional wives.

COLLEEN: Here’s Enitza Templeton again, who we spoke to in Episode Two about why she was originally drawn to be a tradwife.

ENITZA TEMPLETON: I would always say I wanted to be like Betty Crocker, Martha Stewart and June Cleaver all mixed in one.

COLLEEN: What we sought to point out in this series was that today’s tradwives, many of them, are basing their lives on something that was a fabrication of the past.

VICTORIA: As we learned from historians like Elaine Tyler May, the housewife with her pearls and aprons was an invention of the 1950s.

ELAINE TYLER MAY: It’s a fantasy because it creates an idyllic past of a certain gendered middle-class, particularly white middle-class, history that never really existed.

COLLEEN: Women were taught to stay at home, to make the meals and care for the children, for the good of the country, post-World War II, and to boost the economy.

HOUSEWIFE: A place for everything, that sure helps around my kitchen. Everything in its place, that’s easy with my Frigidaire cold pantry.

VICTORIA: And what we wanted to bring attention to is that while this lifestyle might be presented as blissful, quiet, fulfilling, what actually happened when women were relegated to the home was

ELAINE TYLER MAY: A lot of women, they were taking drugs, all kinds of sedatives and antidepressants, not to mention alcoholism, which was really, really rampant in the 1950s among housewives.

COLLEEN: But what I think surprised me is learning how much today’s tradwife is also an invention

VICTORIA: A vehicle to promote right-wing political strategies, like household voting.

DALE PARTRIDGE: Is it good that women can vote in America? I don’t think so.

COLLEEN: So what happens next? Where does this lead?

VICTORIA: You feel like perhaps the tradwife movement has reached a high point and that perhaps, at least in social media pop culture, it’s maybe a bit on the way out. Where does that leave us as a culture with this stained image of the more traditional housewife? Does that also just filter out in the same way it did in the 1950s? Where do you see us, or the tradwife, 10, 15 years from now?

MADELINE PELTZ: It’s tough to say.

VICTORIA: That’s Madeline Peltz again.

MADELINE PELTZ: For me, I see tradwives on the way out, and what I see on the way in is democratic socialism. That’s what I see as the cutting edge of the cultural zeitgeist. It’s really undeniable the way that these ideas are taking hold in unexpected places.

COLLEEN: Here’s the Washington Examiner.

ANNOUNCER: Socialist Melat Kiros defeated longtime Democratic incumbent Diana DeGette in Colorado’s primary Tuesday, signifying growing voter appetite for far-left candidates.

MELAT KIROS: Denver voters of all ages, all religions, sent a clear message: we will not wait.

COLLEEN: This, of course, follows Zohran Mamdani’s historic win in New York City. Here’s NBC.

NBC: Do you still believe in democratic socialism? Do you still think it can be effective?

ZOHRAN MAMDANI: I believe in it even more than I did the day before, and that’s because of the fact that it is focused on the needs of working people, and working people need that focus, that fight from politicians more than ever.

MADELINE PELTZ: You just saw it in Colorado, of course, in New York, and I think you’re going to continue to see more collective visions of culture and labor start to take hold in surprising ways. Over what time period? I don’t know, but that’s what I see as the cultural winds.

VICTORIA: It’s interesting. As a historian, I know that when you look at the grand arc of human history, often before the biggest change, there is the most violent, desperate backlash from the side that is losing their power to project their ideology and way of life.

COLLEEN: So perhaps this surge in far-right political power in America is the last desperate exhale before massive political transformation.

VICTORIA: It could be. And when it comes to voters, they are becoming increasingly disillusioned with what’s being preached.

MADELINE PELTZ: A lot of that disaffection and nihilism that you see among Gen Z conservatives comes from the inability to live up to gender expectations. Young men are taught to be conquerors, to be providers and protectors. The economy doesn’t, it’s no longer possible to live up to those same social expectations that their grandfathers were held to. What you see is this resentment and frustration against the system building. Many of them have invested their hopes for a change in the Trump movement. The Trump movement has let them down. They’re very much up for grabs.

COLLEEN: Changes are afoot. I certainly don’t want “girlboss” back.

VICTORIA: Although I sort of liked millennial pink?

COLLEEN: But I’d like to see more powerful role models for my daughters to look up to. And it’s not the tradwives.

VICTORIA: Even as we are seeing the far right talk about repealing the 19th Amendment, there’s an equal chorus talking about the possibilities (perhaps the fear?) of a woman president.

ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ: My ambition is to change this country. [cheers from crowd]

VICTORIA: That, of course, is Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Here she is, talking at a University of Chicago event about how she doesn’t make decisions like the powerful men currently in charge.

ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ: I make decisions by waking up, looking out the window and observing the conditions of this country, and saying, what move, what decision can I make today to get us closer to that future, stronger, faster, better than yesterday.

COLLEEN: Perhaps there’s more hope than we think, even though there’s been so much damage done: cuts to science (especially women scientists), threats to our voting system, a reduction of women’s reproductive rights.

VICTORIA: Yes. And the long-term impacts when it comes to judicial appointments, defunded climate initiatives and public health programs, the consequences remain to be seen.

COLLEEN: We really are at a critical moment in our country.

VICTORIA: But if we let history be our guide, when it comes to women gaining more political power, we can see there’s actually been a lot of progress, even though it’s often one step forward, two steps back.

COLLEEN: We thank all the historians and experts who joined us for this podcast.

VICTORIA: And we thank you for listening.

COLLEEN: This has been The Story Exchange. If you like this podcast, please share on social media or post a review wherever you listen. It helps other people find the show. And visit our website at thestoryexchange.org, where you'll find news, videos and tips for entrepreneurial women. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, YouTube and Bluesky, and sign up for our free weekly newsletter.

VICTORIA: I'm Victoria Flexner. My co-host is Colleen DeBaise. Sound editing provided by Nusha Balyan. Production coordinator is Noël Flego. Executive producers are Sue Williams and Victoria Wang. Our mixer is Pat Donahue. Recorded at Cutting Room Studios in New York City and Noatune in London.